Friday, September 9, 2011

De Nantes à Normandie

As so often happens, a recent discussion about one subject set me off on a tangent, which eventually got me here, writing this blog. The original discussion was about ‘lost’ folk knowledge, things that had fallen out of style or favor, and were no longer passed down except in books, and it reminded me of a rather special culture that I have an extremely vested interest in:




Who?
‘Les Bretons’, or the people of Brittany (a part of France indicated roughly on the map below) were Celts, and historically independent from both the French and the British.
There was a rather long history of struggles between French and Breton armies all through the middle ages, but eventually Brittany became part of France. In spite of being ostensibly French, ‘les Bretons’ held on to their way of life until the second world war, when, unfortunately, several Breton nationalist leaders collaborated with the Nazis to aid in the quick surrender of France.
Sadly, that betrayal led to a strong pressure to renounce ‘Breton’ culture and language after the war, and just like that, a beautiful culture began dying, taking with it much of what was best in it. At the end of the 20th century, however, a general movement towards reintegration of Breton culture began. Slowly, much of Brittany is starting to resemble the proudly independent Celtic region it once was.
What were their traditions like?
In the past, the Bretons lived a lot like the other Celtic cultures with which they are most closely related. This short clip should give you some idea what they dressed like and the style of dance they performed (feel free to browse the links on the side if you want to see more)
The women wore very distinctive ‘hats’ which were often worked into their hair to keep them from falling as they danced. Their dances and songs had a definite Celtic feel, as you can see if you watch some of the clips. Probably the part of their culture that has survived best is their cooking; if you have ever eaten a crêpe, you are indebted to Breton culture for surviving the centuries! Many Breton traditional foods have become what we think of as distinctively French, crêpes and caramel most likely being the two most significant contributions.
Returning to the discussion of folk knowledge, one of the most amazing examples I have seen was when ‘une bonne mamie Bretonne’ showed me how to make crêpes; she handed me a bowl with milk in it and said, “I use this much for four people.” When I started to ask how much it was, she looked at me strangely and said “That much! Can’t you feel it?” She had learned from her mother, seventy years earlier, to measure her crêpes just by feel, she still remembered, and she was enormously proud of her skill!
While it is certainly true that much of the Breton culture is likely to never reach the level of folk knowledge again, there is still hope for some revival of the culture. The Breton language is again being taught (as an elective) in schools. People with Breton heritages are beginning to refer to themselves as ‘Breton’ in place of ‘French’, and some will even defend themselves if you try call them French. If things go according to plan, someday, it will be common for people to speak the Breton language to their families in their homes, and to speak French in public or at school, and when that happens, maybe some of what was folk knowledge will once again be passed on from parents to children and begin to be a living culture again.
This culture skipped almost two full generations, and it remains to be seen whether it still has the strength in it to recover from that loss. Even if it does survive, who knows how changed it will have been? Still, I’m very optimistic about the future of this beautiful culture.
Oh, did I mention? My fiancée, Camille, is from Brittany, hence the interest in the west of France. =)

7 comments:

  1. People who's culture has been attempted to be wiped out is an interesting topic; because many different culture have been wiped out over the ages. The Egyptian culture is one in particular that comes to my mind. The whole of the Egyptian language was wiped out until the Rosetta Stone was discovered. Can you imagine having accomplished all of the huge pyramids and murals and then not having anyone be able to understand your hieroglyphics. That would really be a downer after all of the work that had been done to build their many wonderful structures.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Reading your post I slowly realized just how right you are... a culture is simply a collection of folk knowledge! Think about it! Everything that makes them unique (the traditional dances, the preparation of the food, the clothing they wear,etc) is a kind of folk knowledge that only they have! That's why we work so hard to preserve such cultures. It's vital that we hold on to the bits of folk knowledge only they have. Excellent topic, really got me thinking.

    PS. I couldn't find your clip of the dances and traditional dance. Please post it if you can! I'd like to see it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks, Jake, you said it even better than I did; I couldn't think of quite how to put it, but I think that you are right. By and large, a culture is defined by its folk knowledge!

    I don't know why the link didn't copy, and I'm having no luck at embedding the video, so I'll just paste the link to a traditional song in the Breton language;

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiNmn7a6_bk

    Also, here is a link to a few seconds of one of their dances, in traditional dress;

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5aFDScE-lTw

    I love their hats! Explore the other links on those two videos if you're interested in seeing more.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved this post. It was really interesting to learn about an unknown culture to me. Definitely brings up many things to mind.
    Especially how folk knowledge can be both similar and different in comparison to a whole variety of cultures.
    Excellent choice of topic!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I totally agree with you guys that a culture is basically a collection of folk knowledge, it seems so obvious now haha. I'm glad you chose this topic because I honestly had no idea there was a separate culture from French in that area. It makes me start to wonder how many other cultures around the world that many of us have never heard of because of the change in the passage of knowledge and how some of them may no longer exist today.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A very interesting post, and especially this idea about losing and recovering folk traditions. Montana's point about the Egyptians is very apt, too.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's very interesting, I never realized this before I served a mission in France, but all of Europe is a lot more culturally diverse than I had ever thought. For example, there are several other pre-franco cultures that lived in France, and some of them still preserve their cultures today. In parts of Italy, people still speak old dialects with family and close friends, and Italian is (as I understand it) what we would call the "father tongue", the language of schools and books and science. The entire continent has a very culture from ours.

    ReplyDelete